Basic + Awesome Creamy Potato Soup

Woman holding a pot of Creamy Potato Soup

I haven’t been excited about much in the last three months.

But here it is: I am, in fact, excited today about the start of a brand-new series.

It’s called Feeding a Broken Heart, and it’s a collection of recipes that are the food equivalent of a million hugs.

As you guys know, life has made me an expert on the topic of feeding a broken heart after the early birth and passing of our sweet baby boy, Afton, just two and half months ago. In the first few weeks after losing Afton, I found myself unable to eat. We’re talking about long periods of time with zero food. I know. Me. Food girl. Not able to eat food. It was all wrong, but my heart was so heavy. I just literally could not. There would be times that I would sit with a bowl of oatmeal in front of me and stir it and mix it and stare at it but literally not be able to take even one bite. “You need to eat,” everyone told me, and I knew it was true. Food would help me heal, both physically and emotionally. But not even the most silky smooth Pad Thai noodles or the warmest gooey chocolate brownies could work their magic on my broken heart. Food was straight-up offensive.

You have to understand: normally, I am a person whose life is built around food. Skipping breakfast, forgetting to eat lunch – who are the people who say these things? I have never understood.

But now I understand, in my own way. I became the opposite of hungry. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner would pass me by, either completely unnoticed, or with some misplaced frustration about how food was supposed to be appealing to me, and it wasn’t, and how could I be expected to like ANYTHING right now? My stomach was full of rock-heavy grief and my heart was – still is – will forever be, in some ways – broken to its core. In the beginning, there was no room for food in this sad house.

How To Make Our Creamy Potato Soup (1 Min):

Creamy Potato Soup in a pot with a wooden spoon

But do you know what happened?

The helpers showed up. And they started bringing us meals.

Our friends reminded us of how to eat when we couldn’t even remember what we liked to eat or how to pour our own bowls of cereal. Sometimes they brought us Pinch of Yum favorites, and sometimes they delivered restaurant gift cards, and sometimes they introduced us to new recipes. Sometimes they dropped meals off and stayed for a visit, and sometimes they slipped away quietly, just leaving a card and maybe some flowers and a big Pyrex container of soup.

For example, basic + awesome creamy potato soup.

creamy potato soup in a bowl with a spoon

So before we talk about the food, I want you to know that this series is a close-up look at what it means to feed a broken heart, whether that broken heart belongs to you or someone you love. These are the recipes that brought (er, currently are bringing) me back to life.

And this series comes with a challenge: we want you to practice feeding a broken heart, whether that broken heart belongs to you or someone you love.

Join Our Mini-Movement:

  1. Think of someone who has a broken heart. I know, there are lots. Loss, breakup, diagnosis, anything. Got it?
  2. Make them one of the extra-comforting recipes in this series. Or… just any recipe. Or give them a restaurant gift card. Or bring them a chocolate bar. Use food to show them that you care.
  3. Show us your awesome love-sharing by using the hashtag #feedingabrokenheart. (Preferably on Instagram which is where I live my alternate internet life 24/7/365, but I guess anywhere will work. We check ’em all.)

As they come in, we will be rounding up some of your inspiring, love-filled stories and featuring them on our Feeding a Broken Heart page. ♡

And if you make THIS SPECIFIC basic + awesome creamy potato soup recipe, we would love to feature it on this post. 🤗

Creamy Potato Soup in two bowls with a spoon and pieces of bread

Alright now. A quick word about this creamy potato soup.

It is the epitome of back-to-basics comfort food. Pair it with a slice of crusty white bread (may I STRONGLY SUGGEST the no-knead bread?) with a thick slather of butter and a sprinkle of sea salt and the long-gone appetite is going to find it’s way back. Better yet, even if the appetite doesn’t show up, this is the kind of food that you can eat with no appetite because it’s mellow and basic in the best possible way. No flashy flavors or ingredients – just good ol’ potatoes, carrots, celery, onion, and bites of bacon in a creamy homemade soup base.

Thank you to my sweet friend Liz for bringing this basic and wonderful soup into my life.

And psst. Guys. Don’t forget the bread.

Creamy Potato Soup in bowl with a spoon.

Basic + Awesome Creamy Potato Soup

  • Author: Pinch of Yum
  • Total Time: 1 hour 15 minutes
  • Yield: 4-6 servings


Creamy Potato Soup – so simple and all-homemade, with carrots, celery, potatoes, milk, butter, flour, and bacon. perfect comfort food with no canned cream-of-anything soups.


  • 6 slices bacon
  • 4 tablespoons butter
  • 2 cups mirepoix (celery, carrots, and onions, all minced)
  • 3 cloves garlic, minced
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt and/or seasoning (to taste, see notes)
  • 1/4 cup all purpose flour
  • 3 cups whole milk
  • 12 cups chicken broth
  • 2 russet potatoes, peeled and cubed


  1. Bacon Prep: Bake the bacon on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper at 400 degrees for 20 minutes. Crumble or cut into pieces.
  2. Soup Base: Melt the butter in a soup pot. Add the mirepoix, garlic, salt, and seasoning and sauté until nice and soft. Add flour and stir with the vegetables for a few minutes to cook off any floury taste. Add milk, just a little bit at a time, stirring after each addition until smooth and creamy. The soup should start out very thick and eventually thin out as you add milk. Add the potatoes, and add chicken broth as needed to achieve the right consistency. For a thicker soup, you may not need as much of the broth.
  3. Simmer Time: Let the soup simmer for 30-40 minutes. The potato soup will thicken as it simmers, and even more as it cools down. I like to wait until the potatoes are almost melty, with their edges softened just a bit, before removing from heat. When ready to serve, crumble the bacon and stir it into the soup.



Seasoning can kind of be whatever you want it to be. I like to use a little bit of sage, and I’ve also used a basic chicken seasoning mix which has thyme, rosemary, oregano, etc.

  • Prep Time: 15 mins
  • Cook Time: 1 hour
  • Category: Dinner
  • Cuisine: American

Keywords: potato soup, creamy soup, soup recipe

Recipe Card powered by Tasty Recipes logo

Creamy potato soup to honor Afton @pinchofyum #feedingabrokenheart

A post shared by Lori Buboltz (@lorieboots) on

Broken Heart Series banner.


Creamy potato soup to honor Afton @pinchofyum #feedingabrokenheart

A post shared by Lori Buboltz (@lorieboots) on

One More Thing!

This recipe is part of our coziest comfort food recipes page. Check it out!

The post Basic + Awesome Creamy Potato Soup appeared first on Pinch of Yum.

Back to blog